It has been quite some time since I’ve read anything by Doug Wilson. The constant controversy turned me off. But I had been meaning to read To a Thousand Generations: Infant Baptism- Covenant Mercy for the People of God for a few years. I lacked opportunity. Teaching a class on baptism provided the opportunity. So I took it.
Like many of Doug Wilson’s books it is not very think. It can be a quick read that touches on the most important aspects of the issue. He doesn’t go overboard, and this one clocks in at just over 100 pages. I know, some of you are thinking that 100 is too many pages for something that “doesn’t exist” in Scripture.
I think Wilson does a good job proving you wrong on that regard. He opens with the problem of nominalism in churches. This topic is never far from the surface of this book. He revisits it often. Sadly, some lay nominalism at the feet of infant baptism. This is utterly erroneous for many/most baptistic churches are also plagued by nominalism. It is not something particular, or peculiar, to churches that practice infant baptism (from a covenantal view).
In this regard Wilson brings up the problem of an “over-realized ecclesiology” (my term, I think). Many advocates of believer’s baptism strive for a “pure” church or a “regenerate” church membership. This includes some the “new Calvinists”. This is a good goal- not letting pagans into church membership. But the Scriptures are honest in that under both covenants there would be a mixed assembly- both covenant keepers and covenant breakers would be there. The only ‘pure’ church will be in the New Jerusalem. The visible church is not comprised only of the elect- that would be the invisible church.