About half way through the movie, CavWife said “I’m confused.” “Me too.”
We were confused, I think, because we were supposed to be put in the shoes of the detectives trying to solve this crime. They know John Holmes is involved, but they don’t know if he is someone caught up in something he didn’t expect, or the man behind it all.
Wonderland is based on a true story of a brutal murder in Hollywood. The man at the center of it all was former porn star John Holmes. The movie refers to his past, and references his claim to fame, but it has nothing directly to do with the porn industry.
At this point in his life, Holmes was a drug addict who moved in very questionable company. As the story unfolds you discover he knows both a drug dealer who was robbed, and the robbers (and their significant others) who end up dead. As the police investigate they come across one of the robbers, who was out of town the night of the murders, who swears John Holmes was behind it all.
So the story is told through the robber’s eyes, John Holmes eyes, the eyes of his girlfriend and finally through the eyes of his wife. This is why it was so confusing. You are left to sort out the truth. The story and director will lead you there, but at times you just aren’t sure who to believe.
This movie has an outstanding cast. Val Kilmer plays a convincing John Holmes. Kilmer is one of my favorite actors, and the reason I wanted to see this movie. It also features Josh Lucas (Sweet Home Alabama), Dylan McDermott (The Practice) and Tim Blake Nelson (O Brother, Where Art Thou?) as part of the gang of drug users who rob “The Arab”. Eric Bogosian (CSI: Criminal Intent) plays “The Arab”, a gangster who runs drugs among other things. Lisa Kudrow plays John Holmes’ wife. Ted Levine (Monk, Silence of the Lambs) plays the lead detective on the case. So, you see it has some great actors.
The story itself has little to no redemption- it is about the earthly wages of sin. These people are self-destructive, and destroy others in the process. John Holmes’ life is testimony to how the “adult movie industry” contributes to the destruction of people’s lives (he eventually died of AIDS in 1988). Holmes’ life is probably the inspiration for much of what P.T. Anderson put in Boogie Nights (a movie about the price desperate people pay for being involved in that industry… it is a horrible spiral into ever increasing depravity).
There is a pivotal scene in Wonderland (the home where the murders took place was on Wonderland) where you see Holmes deceiving himself. This is the point, the power of self-deception. If you tell yourself a lie long enough, it becomes true for you. It seemed as those this was the perspective of the screenwriters- Holmes did it, but deceived himself into thinking he didn’t. If he believed it, the police couldn’t break him.
There is one sex scene early on- depicting how desperate and reckless he and his girlfriend were. There is tons of bad language, and lots of violence as the 2 crimes are told from different perspectives. Sin is never easy to watch. The story does not try to glamorize these people. I was reminded of the last half of Judges where there was no king and the people did what was right in their own eyes. They have thrown off every restraint and descended into a pit from which no one could pluck them. Without hope, they did what they wanted and it ended up destroying them. Seeing this is not pretty. But sometimes we need to see the mask ripped off the pleasant face of sin. Pornography and drugs bring out the worst in people. But this movie will not be for everyone, or many people actually.
Read Full Post »